•  

    Welcome! You are currently logged out of the forum. Some forum content will be hidden from you if you remain logged out. If you want to view all content, please LOG IN!

    If you are not an MOA member, why not take the time to join the club, so you can enjoy posting on the forum, the BMW Owners News magazine, and all of the benefits of membership? If you click here, you have the opportunity to take us for a test ride at our expense. Enter the code 'FORUM25' in the activation code box to try the first year of the MOA on us!

     

JD Powers report on MC Shoppers and Dealer / Brand issues

mika

Still Wondering
I cam across an article over at The Kneeslider.com about this report and found their read and the report itself interesting. I wonder how it resonates with you and what has been previously discussed on the forum? Here is the entire text of the J.D. Powers press release.


J.D. Power and Associates Reports:
Shoppers Cite Dealer-Related Issues among the Top Reasons for Rejecting
Motorcycle Brands

WESTLAKE VILLAGE, Calif.: 10 December 2008
ÔÇö A majority of new-motorcycle buyers reject a motorcycle brand because of dealer-related issues, according to the J.D. Power and Associates 2008 Motorcycle Escaped Shopper StudySM released today.

The inaugural study, which analyzes the reasons shoppers consider a particular motorcycle brand but ultimately purchase a different brand, finds that 51 percent of new-motorcycle shoppers cite dealer-related issues as a reason for rejecting a motorcycle brand. One of the primary dealer-related issues for rejecting a brand is the inability to test ride a bike, which was mentioned by one-fourth of shoppers as a reason for rejection, while 7 percent of shoppers indicate that the inability to test ride was the most influential reason for not purchasing a particular motorcycle brand. In addition, 18 percent of shoppers rejected a motorcycle because it was not available at the dealership, while the perception of being able to receive better service at another dealership is mentioned by 15 percent of shoppers as a reason for rejection.

ÔÇ£To avoid losing customers due to dealer-related issues, itÔÇÖs important for dealers to better manage customer expectations,ÔÇØ said Tim Fox, research manager of the powersports practice at J.D. Power and Associates. ÔÇ£For example, making customers aware before they arrive at the dealership why they can or cannot test ride a particular motorcycle may help brands convert more shopper visits into sales. Since dealer-related issues can be controlled to a certain extent by dealerships and brands, focusing on meeting customer expectations in this regard can result in improved customer perception of a brand as well as lower rejection rates.ÔÇØ

The study also finds that price and financing are cited most often as the reason for rejecting a motorcycle brand, with 57 percent of shoppers mentioning price-related issues as a reason for rejection. Overall, price is cited by 41 percent of shoppers as a reason for rejection, and 28 percent name price as the most influential reason for rejection. Similarly, 16 percent of shoppers mention the lack of low-interest financing, rebates or other incentives as a rejection reason, while 23 percent of shoppers mention high maintenance costs.

ÔÇ£It is important for dealers to understand that for many of these lost sales, there was a legitimate chance of closing the sale during the shopping process,ÔÇØ said Fox. ÔÇ£Eighty-four percent of shoppers indicate they ÔÇÿseriouslyÔÇÖ considered the brand they rejected, and 41 percent indicate they ÔÇÿvery seriouslyÔÇÖ considered the brand. While price is often a major reason for rejection, 51 percent of shoppers end up spending the same or more on the brand they purchased compared with the brand they considered but rejected.ÔÇØ

A vast majority of customers (81%) report having used the Internet to research motorcycles when shopping, 73 percent say they read magazine reviews, and 28 percent say they attended a trade show or motorcycle event, according to the study. Seventy-eight percent of motorcycle buyers indicated they contacted or visited a dealership for information before purchasing.

ÔÇ£More than three-fourths of customers report interacting with a dealership to find more information on a particular motorcycle, so manufacturers have a great opportunity to win or lose customers at this point in the shopping process,ÔÇØ said Fox.

The study, which also examines the impact of gas prices on motorcycle riding habits, finds that 29 percent of motorcycle riders report that they changed their driving habits during late September and early October 2008 when gas prices averaged $3.42 per gallon. Among those riders who changed their habits, 75 percent report using their motorcycle more often for commuting to work or school, and 41 percent say they use their motorcycle more often when driving around town. Additionally, 31 percent report doing less cruising, and 30 percent say they did less extended traveling.

The 2008 Motorcycle Escaped Shopper Study is based on responses from 3,022 new-motorcycle buyers. The study was fielded in September and October 2008.
 
Sounds about right to me, except maybe the importance of test rides. As far as I can tell BMW is a standout, so where are all the Honda and Harley (reject) buyers flocking to buy a BMW after a test ride.
 
Brand rejected due to dealer treatment

I'll concur with that. Before I bought my RT, I had bought a Honda Shadow (cruiser style V-twin) and realized quickly that it was not a good fit for me. I was interested by the GoldWing and went to two dealers. Neither would let me ride one though I rode in on my bike with full gear, MC endorsement on the license AND current insurance policy in place.

I'd made a $6000 mistake with the Shadow and I certainly wasn't going to commit to a $20K mistake with another bike without riding the heck out of it.

Glad they did so because I ended up with my RT instead. Thank you Honda dealers. :kiss
 
I had an RT and was looking at an FJR, but when the dealers, as well as Yamaha USA, told me I couldn't get a test ride except at Americade that did it for me. I will never buy a bike I can't test ride. This is one of the best things BMW can do, and they truely have the most generous test ride policy. I had a weekend test ride of a GT, and guess what I bought one. BMW understands test rides = sales.
 
Dealer Visit Experience

My local BMW dealer completely ignored my young son and I a while back, when I was in a buying mindset. The four guys lounging around at the counter (no other customers) didn't even acknowledge us. We looked at all of the rolling stock, and some gear and left after 20 min.
I would not consider buying much from them after this show of apathy. I'd rather go online and get stellar service.
I bought my R1200C used from a private seller and will do the service myself.
I don't want to be smothered or coddled when I enter a dealership. I do, however, expect to be acknowledged as a potential customer. As a businessman myself, I will not reward this kind of ignorance and neglect. I can understand one person having an off day, but a culture of snobbery, disdain or outright rejection deserves to be rejected itself.
I do applaud BMW dealers for allowing test rides. I would never purchase a motorcycle without one.
Dealerships are individual fiefdoms that require hard work, integrity and word of mouth to survive. Not just hanging a badge on the wall and stocking inventory.
 
My local BMW dealer completely ignored my young son and I a while back, when I was in a buying mindset. The four guys lounging around at the counter (no other customers) didn't even acknowledge us. We looked at all of the rolling stock, and some gear and left after 20 min.
I would not consider buying much from them after this show of apathy. I'd rather go online and get stellar service.
I bought my R1200C used from a private seller and will do the service myself.
I don't want to be smothered or coddled when I enter a dealership. I do, however, expect to be acknowledged as a potential customer. As a businessman myself, I will not reward this kind of ignorance and neglect. I can understand one person having an off day, but a culture of snobbery, disdain or outright rejection deserves to be rejected itself.
I do applaud BMW dealers for allowing test rides. I would never purchase a motorcycle without one.
Dealerships are individual fiefdoms that require hard work, integrity and word of mouth to survive. Not just hanging a badge on the wall and stocking inventory.

Excellent post!

Wish there was a way to send this to all 140+ BMW dealerships in the USA.
 
I don't want to be smothered or coddled when I enter a dealership. I do, however, expect to be acknowledged as a potential customer.

this is key, balance, i don't know what i'd rather be; ignored or smothered. i have only once ever walked into a dealership with the "idea" to buy a new model, generally i'm just there for parts or a magazine or something. i don't like being preyed upon as a potential K1200LT + 3 grand of gear and 5 years of service candidate. luckily, this has only happened once or twice too
 
My local BMW dealer completely ignored my young son and I a while back, when I was in a buying mindset. The four guys lounging around at the counter (no other customers) didn't even acknowledge us. We looked at all of the rolling stock, and some gear and left after 20 min.
I would not consider buying much from them after this show of apathy. I'd rather go online and get stellar service.
I bought my R1200C used from a private seller and will do the service myself.
I don't want to be smothered or coddled when I enter a dealership. I do, however, expect to be acknowledged as a potential customer. As a businessman myself, I will not reward this kind of ignorance and neglect. I can understand one person having an off day, but a culture of snobbery, disdain or outright rejection deserves to be rejected itself.
I do applaud BMW dealers for allowing test rides. I would never purchase a motorcycle without one.
Dealerships are individual fiefdoms that require hard work, integrity and word of mouth to survive. Not just hanging a badge on the wall and stocking inventory.


I think a simple "Hello, I'm (insert name) and I'll be over here (not over your shoulder) if you have any questions" is the best d@mn sales technique there is.
Courteous and available, but out of the way.
 
I think a simple "Hello, I'm (insert name) and I'll be over here (not over your shoulder) if you have any questions" is the best d@mn sales technique there is.
Courteous and available, but out of the way.

Agreed, you should be welcomed and allowed to browse, with the knowledge that there is someone handy to answer questions. I help out very part time at a Victory/Polaris dealership. The idea is to be around without being a pest. I enjoy just hearing bike stories, so it is easy to make conversation without trying to sell anything. In the end, whether you buy nothing, a pair of gloves or a $25k bike, it should be a pleasant experiance.
 
Never dis the deep pockets

My Son and I have bought many a motorcycle together, and had the experience a few yrs back of the young punk salesman at another dealership try his "selling technique"

He started out by telling my son his Kawasaki was a rotton bike, and really offended him and me! At the time my sons KLX 110 was just his ticket, the same bike that he would of put next to his bed at night if I would have let him! Pissed him off and the old man... This kid did not get another 10 minutes of our time!

Three years later My Son has a new Suzuki DRX, and we still have that KLX, now with a new fourth gear, and it still kicks ass!
 
Sad but true. Because of dealer related issues (I do not enter the store anymore - too offensive) I cannot and will not recommend our marque of choice to others.

Thank goodness for the internet and some great US BMW dealers.
 
Sad but true. Because of dealer related issues (I do not enter the store anymore - too offensive) I cannot and will not recommend our marque of choice to others.

Thank goodness for the internet and some great US BMW dealers.

Care to expand on that comment?
 
Dealer Experience

Thanks for the comments. I don't want anyone to think I'm trying to disparage the brand BMW. On the contrary, I love the machines that they produce and wish I could afford a couple more...say, an R1200RT, maybe a K bike and something like an older RxxxxxS or Rockster (my GS days are over for the time being).
I have noticed fierce loyalty to certain dealers too! Max's, Morton's, and several others. I also cruise other dealerships occasionally, including (Gasp!) HD!
They usually say hi, ask if I need help finding anything, and let me wander around. Cool.
Being pragmatic (read cheap), I'll probably never buy a suit of gear with the BMW marque, even if it is the some of the best. I'll shop for a deal after doing some research and asking questions, and might even buy used. That's just because I have a few hobbies that could put a financial hurting on someone with a lot more resources than me.
Brand loyalty is hard to measure or quantify. If Toyota knew how much I like their products, I'd be hearing from them a lot more often than I do. I just have never had to take any of mine to the dealer.
An experience with Dell led me to swear them off even though I like(d) their products... An extended family that swears by a certain brand, purchases oodles of them, yet is treated like s**t will hurt a company with word of mouth more than that company can ever realize (I know lots of people).

I'm stepping down from my soapbox now,
Thanks for listening.
Cheers
 
Care to expand on that comment?

1 - Bike was assembled and placed on showroom floor contrary to what was requested at purchase. Owner laughed it off.

2 - 7 year old helmet sold as NOS. No longer warrantied by manuf. but the "distributor" will provide guarantee.

3 - Bike brought in specifically for EWS work order. Appointment made 1 week in advance. They did not order the part. Assured that I would not be stranded. Wrong - 10 hour tow to Moncton/Dieppe. Not fun but on the plus side I have an appreciation for Atlantic Motoplex - Cool dealership.

4 - Wanted to order a VStream windshield in August - Not in stock. Late September - Sorry not in stock. Guess what they do not deal with Z Technik. Not sure if they figured it out yet.

5 - Sign at service - BMW rims are easily damaged because of the soft metal.

6 - 600 mile check-up. Sorry you'll have to wait a month.

7 - Point 2 - Helmet was bought for my mother - I love my mother and that kind of attitude is just plain offensive. Money over safety - who knew.

8 - Had to do the legwork with respect to the wrong (severly wrong) back tire installed on the bike.

And to those who purchase a BMW in my area all I can say is Caveat Emptor.

If you have a good dealer in your area I'm happy for you.
 
To sum it up it comes down to attitude. You only find out the true colors of a dealership after the sale.

I am in to follow up questions today it seems.

Canadian members seem to be as conflicted in the views about BMW dealers as on the US side of the boarder. BMW CA and BMW NA are two different entities. There are 18 BMW dealers in Canada. Could you give us a bit of an oversight into what the dealership is like beyond your experience?
 
Back
Top