skibum69
slave to gravity
five posts later o the same thread by a different inmate
My BMW G650GS - DR Comparo:
The two year comparo is done. In 2009 the wife and I bought these two bikes new. I have ridden both for a total of about 29,000 miles.
================================================================
The ride:
The BMW feels planted, sure footed, regardless of the surface it’s on.
The DR is an athlete, light and quick to respond. It wants to go faster, faster.
Reliability: Both are legendary.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Points in favor of the DR:
Ignition switch easy to reach. Turn signal switch is smooth and easy to operate. The BMW switch is stiff and has an uncertain feel. The gas cap lock on the BMW broke. In short, all of the controls on the Suzuki are easier to use and are of better quality.
DR is 75 pounds lighter.
DR cost exactly 1/2 as much!
Maintenance is easier on the DR, with a sight glass to check the oil. Changing the oil and filter is simple, unlike the BMW which requires the removal of numerous bolts, facades, and covers. Battery in the DR is sealed. BMW uses an old fashioned wet acid/ plate.
Ergonomics and windshield: I constantly struggled with the BMW in search of comfort, changing the seat, adding bar risers, trying multiple windshields. A number of specialty aftermarket windshields are available for the BMW at $300 ~ $400. None of them work to my expectations. Any one of a number of less than $100 windshields simply bolt to the Suzuki and work fine. A left over $60 Slipstreamer is on there now. The ergo’s required no change, but the seat did.
Those bird beak fenders on BMW’s make no sense to me. A sub fender is then required, to clog with mud. WTF! Adds weight too.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What the BMW does have that the DR does not:
Fuel injection.
More than enough wattage to power heated clothing, aux lights, etc.
================================================================
What I figured out: A lot of little things like stiff switches and overly complicated maintenance kept bugging me about the BMW. Bottom line is, I prefer Japanese engineering. I took wholesale value to get rid of the BMW.
My BMW G650GS - DR Comparo:
The two year comparo is done. In 2009 the wife and I bought these two bikes new. I have ridden both for a total of about 29,000 miles.
================================================================
The ride:
The BMW feels planted, sure footed, regardless of the surface it’s on.
The DR is an athlete, light and quick to respond. It wants to go faster, faster.
Reliability: Both are legendary.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Points in favor of the DR:
Ignition switch easy to reach. Turn signal switch is smooth and easy to operate. The BMW switch is stiff and has an uncertain feel. The gas cap lock on the BMW broke. In short, all of the controls on the Suzuki are easier to use and are of better quality.
DR is 75 pounds lighter.
DR cost exactly 1/2 as much!
Maintenance is easier on the DR, with a sight glass to check the oil. Changing the oil and filter is simple, unlike the BMW which requires the removal of numerous bolts, facades, and covers. Battery in the DR is sealed. BMW uses an old fashioned wet acid/ plate.
Ergonomics and windshield: I constantly struggled with the BMW in search of comfort, changing the seat, adding bar risers, trying multiple windshields. A number of specialty aftermarket windshields are available for the BMW at $300 ~ $400. None of them work to my expectations. Any one of a number of less than $100 windshields simply bolt to the Suzuki and work fine. A left over $60 Slipstreamer is on there now. The ergo’s required no change, but the seat did.
Those bird beak fenders on BMW’s make no sense to me. A sub fender is then required, to clog with mud. WTF! Adds weight too.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
What the BMW does have that the DR does not:
Fuel injection.
More than enough wattage to power heated clothing, aux lights, etc.
================================================================
What I figured out: A lot of little things like stiff switches and overly complicated maintenance kept bugging me about the BMW. Bottom line is, I prefer Japanese engineering. I took wholesale value to get rid of the BMW.