Amver-colored grease might be the clue...
Note: Most of what I wrote is within the quote below---sorry if this is confusing at all
Thanks for all your time and trouble on this, Don, I appreciate it tremendously.
Note: Most of what I wrote is within the quote below---sorry if this is confusing at all
"Not sure what you mean by inside/outside - if you mean the inner race and the outer race.. "
No, Don, I was referring to the edges next to the inside axle spacer---(see my new photos below).
Left:
"Now think about where the seal "seals" - it is fixed on it's outer diameter.. and it seals on the inner diameter, where you have grease. If it's going to leak - that's where the grease would appear."
OK, I understand that.
**********************
"That's a good thing. [ The fact that the bearings turn freely and smoothly ] That doesn't surprise me since there is probably still grease in them, at least some. The only thing that makes me question if it's grease from an external source (like someone greasing the axle before installation - which is supposed to be done, but only a very thin "smear" of grease - is the color. Used grease usually darkens. Looks gray/black in color. This looks like it's white/yellow, which would be a lithium based grease, of the kind someone might spray on an axle when installing it."
Axle pretty much the same as when I removed it:
Yes, most of this grease is amber in color which leads me to believe you're onto something here. Could it be extra grease applied to the inside of the spacers upon reassembly?
It even says right on page 589 of my Clymer; "2. Apply a small amount of cold grease to the inner surface of the spacers; this will help hold them in place."
I'm hoping that this is the key to solving this mystery and here's some close-up photos of the bearings and the spacers I took this morning: (Right side is shown first)
Left side bearing had already been wiped before photos:
Even though it may be impossible to draw a full conclusion one way or the other I am interested to see what you and anyone else might think after seeing these photos.
Is amber grease ever used in the bearings themselves? I would tend to think that BMW is completely consistent in the grease they use and that any amber-colored grease would have been applied after the bearings were originally installed.
Lee, Paul, Greg, or any forensic scientists care to weigh in on this discussion? I'm not doubting one bit of anything that Don is saying, just want to know if anyone else has come across a similar scenario to mine and what the outcome might have been.
Regardless, I will heed Don's bottom line if I am still in doubt about the condition of my bearings:
.. ."I don't think there is any good way to determine if the bearings are leaking given the circumstances - and given the potential badness of a front wheel bearing failure, better safe than sorry."
Thanks for all your time and trouble on this, Don, I appreciate it tremendously.