Fiddling with Fidlock

[cap]

I recently bought a new helmet that has (gasp!) D-ring closures. How primitive! Well, they are titanium at least. But I wanted something faster, and I am accustomed to a micro-ratchet closure. So, I found this Fidlock buckle on Amazon, and I gave it a try.

It works great. I thought it might be too hard to install, or not strong enough, or that it might be likely to slip off. But none of those concerns are warranted. An added benefit is that it is more comfortable than the D-rings when snugged. Another benefit is that my riding buddies have Fidlock-envy. Priceless.

Cap

 

[cap]

I took a video of the helmet clasp.

 

[T-foiler]

Looks dangerous to me. I couldn’t trust a magnet to protect my head. Have you tested it with lots of force? This isn’t a personal attack, just not educated about the product.

 

[cap]

Looks dangerous to me. I couldn’t trust a magnet to protect my head. Have you tested it with lots of force? This isn’t a personal attack, just not educated about the product.

The magnet pulls the latch closed. The latch is very strong, and can’t open accidentally. These are being used in a variety applications, including helmets. It is a very clever product.

 

[paul_f]

My first helmet, Schubert, had a racheting method for locking the strap; later helmets were all D Rings. I found the ratcheting strap to be very uncomfortable and personally prefer the D Ring.

I expect that I am most likely in the minority

 

[bigjohnsd]

My Klim Krios helmet has a Fidlock.
Originally I was concerned about it coming open/remaining latched.
So far so good, only one testing dirt nap, I didn't hit my head, the helmet stayed on.
Sure is easy to use, Latchable/Unlatchable with gloves on once you learn how.
Very positive indication of closure/latching.

 

[brownie0486]

My first helmet, Schubert, had a racheting method for locking the strap; later helmets were a!l D Rings. I found the ratcheting strap to be very uncomfortable and personally prefer the D Ring.

I expect that I am most likely in the minority

I don't think you're in the minority. I wouldn't trust that fidlock in a crash [ not a get off but a crash ] to remain locked. More power to those with more faith I suppose

 

[36654]

D rings are several pages down on my list of annoyances.......

But, that's just me.

 

[brownie0486]

D rings are several pages down on my list of annoyances.......

But, that's just me.

 

[lkraus]

The Fidlock magnet only holds the latch closed, just as a lightweight spring does on other strap latches. The magnet never has to resist crash forces on the chin strap. Fidlock buckles are stock on some helmets which pass ECE standards.

 

[PGlaves]

The Fidlock magnet only holds the latch closed, just as a lightweight spring does on other strap latches. The magnet never has to resist crash forces on the chin strap. Fidlock buckles are stock on some helmets which pass ECE standards.

Too modern for some folks.

 

[brownie0486]

Too modern for some folks.

For myself, it's not that it's modern, it's that it's unproven in a crash. The only way my D ring fails is if the strap is cut somehow.

 

[rogerc60]

Fidlock buckles are stock on some helmets which pass ECE standards.

... it's that it's unproven in a crash.

Can both of these be true at the same time?

 

[cap]

Too modern for some folks.

I remember when people first started using a "smart phone," and thinking "who needs that?"

 

[brownie0486]

Can both of these be true at the same time?

I'd think no actual crash testing was performed. Drop test, lock strength tests, any of a number of mechanical testing likely, but actually crash testing the buckle? Highly unlikely.

Once enough people have actually crashed using this buckle and there's no evidence of failures, it may pass my smell test

 

[dlong]

Question for cap...did you have to remove the snap from the long end of the strap to fit the Fidlock device? Considering the price, I'd give it a try if I can return the strap to normal function if I don't like the Fidlock.

 

[cap]

Question for cap...did you have to remove the snap from the long end of the strap to fit the Fidlock device? Considering the price, I'd give it a try if I can return the strap to normal function if I don't like the Fidlock.

Yes, you have a good eye. The snap will not pass the slots on the fidlock latch. I snipped the snap.

On the other side, I just left the D-rings on. Like you, I wanted to be able to reverse the changes if I didn’t like it. And I never use the snap anyway, so for me it was no big deal.

However, it took some careful manipulation to slip the notched end into the D-ring loop. That would be challenging to remove... but that is the whole point after all.

 

[lkchris]

The new FIM helmet standard--required for MotoGP, World Superbike, etc. riders--mandates D-rings.

 

[fmdualexhaust]

I'm a D ring fan.

 

[zimmermanj]

I believe for a racing helmet that might be crashed at high speeds the D-rings are absolutely the way to go. I would want D-rings on any helmet I raced in. But the micro-ratchet designs are just too darn convenient for the street, such that not having a micro-ratchet is a deal-breaker for me for a street helmet.