I just bought some Pinlock ear plugs (Amazon and Revzilla carry them). They are about the most comfortable I have tried and only cost about $25 for set of bot medium and large earplugs.
I too have a set of these.
Before purchasing, I read quite a few reviews. By far most were very favorable, but some were decidedly not. I wondered about those negative reviews, but ordered some anyway.
I now understand the unfavorable reviews. For me, these are COMPLETELY ineffective at reducing wind noise. There must be something different about the physiology of my ears, because they don’t work at all for me.
The good news is they only cost about $25 so not the end of the world if you take a chance and they don’t work out.