• Welcome, Guest! We hope you enjoy the excellent technical knowledge, event information and discussions that the BMW MOA forum provides. Some forum content will be hidden from you if you remain logged out. If you want to view all content, please click the 'Log in' button above and enter your BMW MOA username and password.

    If you are not an MOA member, why not take the time to join the club, so you can enjoy posting on the forum, the BMW Owners News magazine, and all of the discounts and benefits the BMW MOA offers?

Photo Assignment 05/30/08

Me. In the Southern Adirondacks... On a 73 R75/5 Toaster...
...as seen thru a box camera...

<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/jim_popper/458990172/" title="Heading to the Adirondacks by Poppr, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm1.static.flickr.com/221/458990172_632b47422e_o.jpg" width="297" height="281" alt="Heading to the Adirondacks" /></a>
 
Garnet Lake NY...

<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/jim_popper/349177067/" title="TheCove by Poppr, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm1.static.flickr.com/140/349177067_7016a94cf8_o.jpg" width="1024" height="768" alt="TheCove" /></a>
 
Feedback

Before I begin, I would like to thank everyone once more for their congratulations on the birth of my second daughter, Mia. Your kind words are very much appreciated. At two weeks and two days I am thrilled to report she nearly slept through the entire night, and I have some energy to devote to other obligations


Reflections_001_752x500.jpg
Kartoon joins us this week with a nice ÔÇ£double reflectionÔÇØ shot which finds art in the mundane. The background behind the TV looks a little cluttered, and I may have tried to include more of the TV itself, but the Corvette and itÔÇÖs reflection off the floor (which is far too clean in my opinion) are very well framed inside the TV screen.


BoxerÔÇÖs second post is a real winner in my opinion. Aptly named ÔÇ£The Magic WindowÔÇØ, the reflection in the panes nicely replaces the background of the barn ceiling. As is an issue with many reflection shots, choice of focal point could change the image quite a bit. I see the window as the subject, but the focal point draws my eye to the trees in the reflection. I would prefer to see more of the interesting detail in the wooden window and barn really stand out. BoxerÔÇÖs section of perspective and framing are what really makes this shot.


Bony chimes in with an excellent reflection photo of what appears to be controls on a fire engine. Focus and exposure are spot on giving a clear and crisp view of the well-polished machine. I am a little distracted by the change in background to the right, but changing the angle to show only the controls might have compromised the perspective. This many reflections can be hard to manage, but Bony takes care not to show any recognizable image of the photographer.


Voni takes some time from her epic sojourn to Alaska to post this unique rest-stop shot reminiscent of a classic movie travel sequence. Paul and the bikes are nicely positioned within the white spaces of the map (although the blue lines are a bit distracting), and the depth of field keeps the map in focus to tell the story.


<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/srab/2540271264/" title="Reflections by sheridesabeemer, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3275/2540271264_83ca7fde50_o.jpg" width="800" height="533" alt="Reflections" /></a>
This is a nice image of Gail and her daughter [and her daughter] sharing their appreciation of photography. The lighting is warm and inviting, and I am a real sucker for candid photographs of photographers. Closing the aperture just a bit and using a slower shutter speed could have increased the depth of field to put her and her daughter into slightly better focus, but the even spacing of the ÔÇ£threeÔÇØ photographers and the rather consistent distance from her daughter to the window and from her to her daughter gives an excellent balance to this reflection shot.


BeerTeam weighs in again this week with a trio of excellent reflection images. While the others are beautiful, this signature mirror shot stands out to me. I may have preferred the mirror to be positioned a bit differently, but it is clear that he has made subtle compromises for the purpose of framing both the scene in the reflection and the scene in the background.


Jantarek joins us this week with a nice study in reflections. Although he admits there could be modifications, this shot shows interesting composition, color and style. I like his hand position in the way his fingers grip the sphere, and the position of the logo within the frame.


Paul answers Voni with a near-professional quality photo. This is an excellent example of choice in location and in subject matter really making the difference. The tree in the foreground breaks up the reflection of the mountain in the pond, and I am curious to know what effect a little zoom would give, but overall a magnificent scene! I can almost feel the cool clean mountain air.


Rocketman joins us again this week for another trio of thoughtful images, but this solitary goose gives such a quiet feeling of serenity. The relatively low light for such a high zoom may have caused a slight blur, but it looks like the VR may have kicked in to lend a hand. Nice balance of subject and reflection.


Of BeemerchefÔÇÖs two images, this one is outstanding. His choice to expose to the beautiful canyon walls makes the light seem as if it is burning its way through the ceiling, and the dust in the air only helps to accentuate the sun-beam. Although this appears to have been cropped and, if so, would not conform to the rules of the assignment, this image is near to perfection.


This sentimental reflection from Lorazepam embraces the assignment of both levels. We see the appreciation of lifeÔÇÖs joys while reflecting on a lost companion. Where this image could benefit from a slight change in angle to give the tank a more unique perspective, it more than makes up for it in sentimental impact. Thank you for sharing this with us.
 
Honorable Mentions

<img border=2 width=800 src=http://bmwdean.home.att.net/reflections.jpg>
Although taken outside the timeframe of the photo assignment, Bmwdean shared this wonderful motorcycle reflection shot. The double reflection works very well here to feature both bikes, and the perspective gives an interesting dimension to the foreground tank. A greater depth of field here may add more interest to all three primary reflections, but the blur almost serves to further blend the chrome and color into a beautiful BMW collage.

Grafikfeat shared some interesting photos which are also outside the timeframe. This one appears to have been slightly retouched as well. With just enough helmet and the other rider in perfect position, this is one of the best helmet portraits I have seen.

Also outside the timeframe, this is another great early fall reflection shot merits inclusion. Aside from the vivid colors, I particularly like the morning mist dancing across the water.
 
Wow! Once more!

Masterful descriptions that bring out so much more than I can ever see in the submissions. I learn so much from each of these assignments.

Thanks for sharing your talents with us all.

Voni
sMiling in Fort Nelson, British Columbia
 
WowÔÇöI've really been out of the loop. Just got back into town.

Very nice assignment Alex. Loved your feedback. I also really admire the photography. Some really nice stuff this time around.
 
Took this one today, thought I'd share. ;)

<a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/srab/2679707121/" title="License & Registration by sheridesabeemer, on Flickr"><img src="http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3083/2679707121_bcc75f625f_b.jpg" width="1024" height="614" alt="License & Registration" /></a>
 
Grafikfeat shared some interesting photos which are also outside the timeframe. This one appears to have been slightly retouched as well. With just enough helmet and the other rider in perfect position, this is one of the best helmet portraits I have seen.

I been meaning to respond to this... Space is my final frontier... The retouching involved was to crop the right side to square it off and some "burning in" of the sky... The rest is as seen from a box camera held at arms length at 50 mph. I too was rather surprised at the outcome of a $5.99 camera. :p

Thank you for the compliment!
 
Never too late to post.
.

The rules:deal for this thread were "Photos must be shot between Fri. 05/30/08 and Sun. 06/07/08--10 days." I've been reprimanded TWICE:nono for offending sensitive beemer feelings on this forum. With all the a*** retentive types this marque seems to attract I figured I best ask permission first:laugh
 
The rules:deal for this thread were "Photos must be shot between Fri. 05/30/08 and Sun. 06/07/08--10 days." I've been reprimanded TWICE:nono for offending sensitive beemer feelings on this forum. With all the a*** retentive types this marque seems to attract I figured I best ask permission first:laugh

No argument here... Thanks for asking.

I think the rules of these threads are mainly to contain the posts and to ensure the images were taken with the particular concept or technique in mind. There are plenty of places to post the shots you have collected over the years. These assignments and the commentary within them are for those who are interested in further developing their photography.

That being said, if the assignment still resonates well after its official end, what better way to develop the ideas than to use the thread as a showcase for related images? Maybe even to get some feedback once in a while...
 
Back
Top