• Welcome, Guest! We hope you enjoy the excellent technical knowledge, event information and discussions that the BMW MOA forum provides. Some forum content will be hidden from you if you remain logged out. If you want to view all content, please click the 'Log in' button above and enter your BMW MOA username and password.

    If you are not an MOA member, why not take the time to join the club, so you can enjoy posting on the forum, the BMW Owners News magazine, and all of the discounts and benefits the BMW MOA offers?

Poor Compression After Top End Rebuild

wecm31

Luddite Looney
This time last year I checked the compression on my bike and found it to be 125 psi L/ 130 psi R. Those numbers combined with a chipped exhaust valve inspired me to redo the top end. Heads and cylinders went off to a BMW dealer of note, well experienced with airheads and performing in house work. Cylinders were checked, heads had the seats milled and new valves installed. Exhaust valves had new guides installed as well. I resinstalled the heads with new rings, careful to orient the gaps per Oak's manual. Fired the bike up for the first time in the spring with no oil in the cylinders and held rpm at ~ 3000 for a minute. Then went for a 60 mile ride and dumped the oil. Ran a second course of dino 20W50 with some break in additive (ZDDP stuff mainly) and after 250 miles changed that to my preferred 20W50 semi syn (Brad Penn).

Bike ran fine, seemed a bit peppier than last season, so I thought. Didn't campaign at all this year, other issues both bike and nonbike kept me close to home. With only 1200 miles on the season, changed the oil out this week and tucked the bike into storage (snow has arrived in the Great White North).

Here's the kicker....did a compression test after my last ride (carbs off) and both sides are exactly the same at 120 psi. WTF???

Did I not run dino oil long enough? Have I not given it enough time? How long should it take to seat the rings??

Anything else I could be pondering?:scratch

Bike is tucked away till spring, won't be investigating until April now....
 
Last edited:
Gerald -

Sounds like you did everything right...that first minute should have done quite a bit to seat the rings. Lots of varying speed, accels, decels for that first 60 miles. How have the valves been during this time? Does the bike burn any oil that you can tell? If rings are installed upside down, they can literally pump oil into the combustion chamber.

You might have to do a leakdown test in order to find out where the compression is leaking off to. Might be the rings are still seating...I would probably have run the dino oil longer.
 
I think you need to run the Dino oil a lot longer. I would put at least 3,000 miles on it before switching to the Syn. On the newer BMW's some recomend 12,000 miles before switching.
 
I assume you had clean ring grooves. Ring break in has two distinct components. One is the ring to cylinder wall seal. Your scuff in probably did that OK. But the other part of ring sealing is good sealing of the rings to the lands adjacent to the grooves. Combustion pressure is supposed to keep the rings tight against the land, and combustion gasses behind the rings also exert an outward pressure.

Good ring sealing in the grooves requires a slight build up of varnish in the groove. I'd be pretty sure that dino oil is much better at this than synthetic.
 
Thanks for response all!!

I had the pistons cleaned by the dealer, they were ultrasonic soaked I think, came back to me looking like new. I was very careful to follow Oak's manual on the rings, quite confident I put them on right.

First ride was lots of on/off throttle, valve adjustment remained constant.

Didn't really gather enough data on oil usage, hadn't racked enough miles to establish the trend. Don't think it was excessive.

I'll go back to dino next summer, log some miles and repeat the compression test mid summer. Seems I might have got off the dino too soon....

And if that doesn't pan out, a leak down test might be in my future.
 
Brad Penn makes a 30 weight break-in oil. I typically use it for 100-200 miles on VWs and used it on my Airhead (new 1st OS bore) last summer. No ring issues that I can tell, but I've not run a compression test either.
 
I'd be pretty sure that dino oil is much better at this than synthetic.

I know this will sound blasphemous, but the former Butler & Smith mechanic that worked on my '73 R75/5 last year used no oil whatsoever when he reassembled the top end, other than the valves.

He explained that the B&S training philosophy (provided by BMW at the time) was that oil used during assembly basically prevents the rings from seating and tends to glaze the cylinder walls within several hundred stokes. He also claimed that break-in time would be reduced.

Yeah, right, I believe that.

But it worked.
 
I know this will sound blasphemous, but the former Butler & Smith mechanic that worked on my '73 R75/5 last year used no oil whatsoever when he reassembled the top end, other than the valves.

That was my plan as well, I think Cutter suggested it at Supertech if I'm not mistaken.

I used lint free paper towels to carefully dry the rings, cylinders, and pistons.

Cylinders looked really nice BTW, a credit to the Nikasil technology. I am by no means a pro wrench, but I have peered down more than a few cylinder bores, bike/car/snowmobile etc.

And for 140k km (85k mi), they are defect free with the faintest hint of cross hatching from 25+ years of use.

amazing....:german
 
Back
Top