I was browsing the BMW web site yesterday when I saw a link for BMW Performance Insurance; an offering from BMW and Liberty Mutual. It says they offer a discount to BMW riders and has a phone number to get a quote. Since my current insurance renews in July I gave them a call. Here's the numbers I got:
Me - 2006 R1200RT, experienced rider with no recent violations or accidents. I have collision insurance on the bike.
Renew my current policy with Progressive $400
Switch to BMW/Liberty Mutual $609
The two policies aren't exactly the same but I don't see $206 worth of differences. I'll be staying with Progressive.